Pama-Nyungan languages

Pama-Nyungan
Geographic
distribution:		 most of mainland Australia, with the exception of northern parts of Northern Territory and Western Australia
Linguistic Classification: Macro–Pama-Nyungan
 Greater Pama-Nyungan
  Pama-Nyungan
Subdivisions:
—
Australian languages.png

Pama-Nyungan languages (yellow). Garawa is one of the purple languages. Tankic is purple or yellow.

The Pama-Nyungan languages are the most widespread family of Indigenous Australian languages, containing 160 of 228 identified languages.

The Pama-Nyungan family was identified and named by Kenneth Hale, in his work on the classification of Native Australian languages. Hale realised that of the Aboriginal Australian languages, one relatively closely-interrelated family had spread and proliferated over most of the continent, while approximately a dozen other families were concentrated along the North coast. The Pama-Nyungan family accounts for most of the geographic spread, most of the Aboriginal population, and the greatest number of languages.

The name "Pama-Nyungan" is derived from the names of two widely-separated groups, the Pama languages from the Northeast, and the Nyungan languages from the Southwest. The terms pama and nyunga are expressions meaning "man" in the languages from their respective regions.

The other language families indigenous to the continent of Australia are occasionally referred to, by exclusion, as Non-Pama-Nyungan languages, though this is not a proper taxonomic term.

Although counting languages is not, in general, a well-defined operation, there are on the order of hundreds of Pama-Nyungan languages. Most of the Pama-Nyungan languages are spoken by small ethnic groups, with thousands of speakers or fewer. Many are considered endangered languages, and many have recently become extinct.

Contents

Typolgy

Evans and McConvell describe typical Pama-Nyungan languages such as Warlpiri as dependent-marking and exclusively suffixing languages which lack gender, while noting that some non-Pama-Nyungan languages such as Tangkic share this typology and some Pama-Nyungan lanugaes like Yanyuwa, a head-marking and prefixing language with a complicated gender system diverge from it.[1]

Reconstruction

Vocabulary

In addition to Hale's 1982 list of words unique to Pama-Nyungan, and in addition to pronouns and case endings they reconstruct for the proto-language, Evans and McConvell reprt that while some of their roots are implausible, O'Grady and Tryon, nevertheless provide "hundreds of clear cognate sets with attestations throughout the Pama-Nyungan area and absent outside."[2]

Phonology

Proto–Pama-Nyungan's phonological inventory, as reconstructed by Barry Alpher (2004), is quite similar to those of most present-day Australian languages.

Vowels

Front Back
High i iː u uː
Low a aː

Vowel length is contrastive only in the first (i.e. stressed) syllable in a word.

Consonants

Bilabial Apico-
alveolar		 Apico-
postalveolar		 Laminal Dorso-
velar
Stop p t rt c, cʸ k
Nasal m n rn ñ ng
Lateral l rl λ
Rhotic rr r
Semivowel w y

Proto–Pama-Nyungan seems to have had only one set of laminal consonants; the two contrasting sets (lamino-dental and lamino-alveopalatal or "palatal") found in some present-day languages can largely be explained as innovations resulting from conditioned sound changes.

Nevertheless, there are a small number of words where an alveopalatal stop is found where a dental would be expected, which are symbolised as *cʸ. There is no convincing evidence, however, of an equivalent nasal *ñʸ or lateral *λʸ.

Internal classification

According to Nicholas Evans at the Australian National University, the closest relative of Pama-Nyungan is the Garawa isolate, followed by the small Tankic family. He then proposes a more distant relationship with the Gunwinyguan languages in a macro-family he calls Macro–Pama-Nyungan.

A fairly aggressive classification of Pama-Nyungan proper includes approximately 175 languages in 14 extant and numerous extinct branches.

Validity

Dixon's skepticism

In his own 1980 attempted reconstruction of Proto-Australian, R. M. W. Dixon, reported that he was unable to find anything that reliably set Pama-Nyungan apart as a valid genetic group. (Although we should note that demonstrating linguistic relatedness per se and demonstrating that a group of languages comprise a subgroup of a higher order family do not use the same evidence). Fifteen years later, he had abandoned the idea that Australian or Pama-Nyungan were families. He now sees Australian languages as a language area only (Dixon 2002). Some of the small traditionally Pama-Nyungan families which have been demonstrated through the comparative method, or which in Dixon's opinion are likely to be demonstrable, include the following:

He believes that Lower Murray (5 families and isolates), Arandic (2 families, Kaytetye and Arrernte), and Kalkatungic (2 isolates) are small Sprachbunds.

Mainstream rejoinders

However, the papers in Bowern & Koch (2004) demonstrate about ten traditional groups, including Pama-Nyungan, and its sub-branches such as Arandic, using the comparative method.

In his last published paper from the same collection, Ken Hale describes Dixon's skepticism as an "extravagantly and spectacularly erroneous" and "wrong-headed" phylogenetic assessment which is "so bizarrely faulted, and such an insult to the eminently successful practitioners of Comparative Method Linguistics in Australia, that it positively demands a decisive repost." [3] In the same work Hale provides unique pronominal and grammatical evidence (with suppletion) as well as more than fifty basic-vocabulary cognates (showing regular sound correspondences) between the proto-Northern-and-Middle Pamic (pNMP) family of the Cape York Peninsula on the Australian northeast coast and proto-Ngayarta of the Australian west coast, some 3,000 km apart, (as well as from many other languages) to support the Pama-Nyungan grouping, whose age he compares to that of Proto-Indo-European.

See also

References

  1. ↑ Nick Evans and Patrick McConvell, "The Enigma of Pama-Nyungan Expansion in Australia" Archaeology and language, Volume 29, Roger Blench, Matthew Spriggs, eds., Routledge, 1999, p176
  2. ↑ Nick Evans and Patrick McConvell, "The Enigma of Pama-Nyungan Expansion in Australia" Archaeology and language, Volume 29, Roger Blench, Matthew Spriggs, eds., Routledge, 1999, p176
  3. ↑ "the Coherence and Distinctiveness of the Pama-Nyungan Language Family within the Australian Linguistic Phylum" Geoff O'Grady and Ken Hale, p 69, Australian Languages: Classification and the Comparative Method, Claire Bowern and Harold Koch, eds., John Benjamins Pub. Co., Amsterdam and Philadelphia, 2004
Languages of Australia
English varieties
Australian · Australian Aboriginal · Torres Strait
 Australia
Major indigenous
languages
Arrernte · Kala Lagaw Ya · Luritja · Pintupi · Pitjantjatjara · Tiwi · Walmajarri · Warlpiri · Western Desert · Yolŋu Matha
Pidgins, creoles and
mixed languages
Australian Aboriginal Pidgin English · Broome Pearling Lugger Pidgin · Gurindji Kriol · Kriol · Queensland Kanaka English · Torres Strait Creole · Light Warlpiri
Sign languages
Auslan · Australian Aboriginal